During a press conference on May 8, 2024, Lorena Van Assche, an Arizona Hispanic Chamber of Commerce board member, expressed the chamber’s opposition to the Protecting Arizona Against Illegal Immigration Act. Van Assche stated that the act does not make economic sense for the state and could lead to costly litigation if implemented. She also referenced the negative impact that past immigration legislation, such as SB 1070, had on the state’s economy.
Van Assche highlighted that E-verify is already a requirement by law and that Arizona already has strong legal statutes in place to address fraudulent behavior related to immigration. The proposed referral would expand the E-verify requirement to include industries that were previously exempt, such as construction, agriculture, and hospitality. It would also increase legal penalties for employers who do not comply.
The proposal is similar to a bill that was previously vetoed by Governor Katie Hobbs. If approved, the proposal would be presented to voters during the November general elections, bypassing the governor’s veto authority. The Arizona Hispanic Chamber of Commerce opposes the act based on its potential negative economic impact on the state and the existing legal framework already in place to address immigration issues.
In addition to its potential negative economic impact, Van Assche also expressed concern about how this act could negatively affect families and communities in Arizona. She emphasized that while she understands the importance of securing our borders and protecting our citizens from illegal immigration, we must do so in a way that is fair and just for all members of our society.
Furthermore, Van Assche stated that this proposed law would create unnecessary burdens on businesses and individuals alike. It would be difficult for businesses to comply with new regulations without facing significant costs and time constraints.
Overall, Van Assche strongly urged caution before implementing any new immigration policies in Arizona. She encouraged policymakers to consider alternative solutions that are more effective in achieving our goals while minimizing harm to individuals and communities across the state.
The Protecting Arizona Against Illegal Immigration Act is a contentious issue in Arizona politics. Many argue that it is necessary for maintaining law and order in our society but others see it as a violation of civil rights and an economic burden on businesses and individuals alike. As debates continue over this issue, it remains clear that there are no easy answers when it comes to addressing illegal immigration in our country today.